’Tis the Season: Convenience vs Indulgence

When online butcher The Fat Butcher revealed it would be selling turkeys through TikTok Shop this Christmas, retail eyebrows were raised.

A challenger brand, using a social platform once known for memes and dance trends, to muscle in on the festive grocery market? It’s a clever play — and one that encapsulates the new tension in retail: convenience versus experience.

Convenience Grows Up

Convenience has long been retail’s favourite word. The pandemic only accelerated that obsession. From grocery delivery apps to one-click gifting, shoppers have come to expect everything to be frictionless, immediate, and available on demand.

TikTok’s evolution from a social platform to a shopping hub signals how rapidly this expectation is expanding. For The Fat Butcher, it’s a perfect promotional opportunity: a chance to reach consumers where they’re already scrolling, at the precise moment inspiration strikes.

The message to established retailers is clear: challenger brands no longer need physical stores — or even a website — to sell. They can now trade directly within the same feeds consumers use for entertainment.

In a season when time is tight and to-do lists are endless, convenience feels like the ultimate gift.

The Return of Experience

But at Christmas, convenience alone can’t win.

The festive season remains a sensory, emotional, and highly irrational shopping period. Consumers want indulgence. They want theatre. They want to feel something.

That’s where physical retail shines. The smell of mince pies in-store. The sparkle of decorations. The serendipity of discovering something you didn’t know you needed. These are experiences an app can’t replicate.

A shopper might order their turkey through TikTok, but they’ll still leave a Christmas market with bags full of treats they never planned to buy. That’s not inefficiency — it’s festive magic.

And it’s a form of shopping that retailers can own, if they lean into it.

What This Means for Retailers

The lesson here isn’t that social commerce is “the enemy.” It’s that the battleground has shifted.

The Fat Butcher’s TikTok success should serve as a wake-up call — not because it signals the demise of the store, but because it demonstrates how effectively digital-first brands can capture festive attention.

Retailers can (and should) use those same platforms, but to do something challengers can’t: bring the joy, theatre, and sensory magic of Christmas to life.

Think experiential activations, emotional storytelling, and social-first campaigns that lead consumers into store, not away from it.

Because convenience will always drive transactions — but experience drives loyalty.

And at Christmas, loyalty is priceless. TikTok might sell you the turkey, but only retailers can sell you Christmas itself.

‍

✨ Want to create festive experiences people remember?

At N2O, we help brands balance convenience with indulgence — delivering experiential retail activations that drive footfall, emotion, and loyalty at key seasonal moments.

👉 Talk to us and let’s make Christmas unforgettable.

‍